9/9/2001 : I offer encounter a real problem with players
in orchestras who during the course of their careers have come to play
as a matter of course with an appreciable time delay behind the ictusof
the beat, almost to the point where as an audience member it appears the
conductor is conducting with his beat upside down. I have
found this very difficult to adjust to, or persuade the orchestra to make
an adjustment, particularly when there is little rehearsal time.
I have found that a slight delay is preferable for me, and the best orchestras I have worked with tend to play that way. It solidifies the tone and helps ward off unintentional acceleration. It is also true that you have to be able to adapt to an orchestra, especially if you are a guest.
However if the delay is so great as you describe, you will get other distortions. Response time is, to some extent, the work of the concertmaster, and you should work closely with him or her to correct extreme differences. This is much easier for a music director or principal guest than it is for a first-time guest conductor, of course.
Finally, be careful that you are not reacting to a small delay and
slowing down imperceptably. The orchestra will then drop behind that
beat and, if you are not careful, you will drift slower again. These
are tiny differences and it is easy, especially for a new conductor,
to fall into the trap of following more than leading.
© 2001 by Joseph Rescigno. The text here may be freely reproduced for non-commercial purposes as long as credit is given.
|About Joseph Rescigno||Audio & Video Samples||Messages to the Maestro (intro)|
|Click here to return to summary of subjects.|